Justice Lawrence Mugambi of the High Court in Thika ruled that the Sh8,000 fee demanded by police officers for towing a vehicle is unconstitutional, emphasizing that motorists must not face unexplained charges when their cars are impounded.
The judgment, delivered on 12 November 2026, noted that while the Traffic Act allows police to remove and detain vehicles, it does not permit arbitrary towing fees without a transparent, legally justified basis.
The case originated from a 25 December 2025 incident where David Kimani Waithera was stopped during a Juja Police Station alcohol‑related traffic operation and his vehicle, registration KCK 799K, was towed by a civilian operator, Harrison Nzuki, who charged Sh8,000 based on AA rates.
Waithera contested the demand, arguing that the police had not provided an invoice, tariff, or procurement documentation to justify the amount, and that no legal contract with the private tow service existed.
Police defended the charge by citing Sections 106 and 107 of the Traffic Act, which they said authorize vehicle removal and detention in appropriate circumstances.
Justice Mugambi acknowledged that police may engage the nearest towing operator during emergencies but stressed that any fee must be predictable, publicly known, and supported by a clear formula or prescribed tariff.
The judge suspended the Sh8,000 demand pending the outcome of Waithera's traffic case and directed the traffic court to determine liability and, if appropriate, set a payable amount based on evidence.
The Sh8,000 already deposited in court to secure the vehicle's release will remain held until the traffic case is resolved.
Justice Mugambi called for urgent law reform to establish clear regulations governing towing charges during police traffic operations, warning that the current practice could amount to arbitrary deprivation of property under Article 40 of the Constitution.
Comments