The Environment and Land Court ruled that the family of former Prisons Commissioner Philip Arap Kirui must surrender parcel Kericho/Chemagel/1401 in Bomet to three purchasers who bought it at a public auction more than two decades ago.

Justice E. Asati directed the family to deliver vacant possession within 90 days and warned that failure to comply would result in eviction under the law.

The three buyers – Christine Andree Joshi, Stephen Elkington and Barry James Joshi – were represented by lawyer Samuel Makori, who secured a judgment dismissing the family’s fraud allegations.

The court awarded the purchasers Sh500,000 in general damages for trespass and ordered the Kirui family to pay the costs of the suit.

The dispute originates from a March 22, 2002 public auction where the land was sold for Sh800,000 after execution proceedings on a bank loan owed by the late Kirui, who had previously signed a consent decree allowing the bank to recover the debt.

Kirui and his wife, Sally Chebwogen Kirui, challenged the auction in court, but their case was dismissed on June 8, 2010 for want of prosecution and was never overturned.

The purchasers obtained registration and a title deed on March 23, 2012, yet remained unable to occupy the land, prompting a further suit in 2014.

Justice Asati rejected the family’s fraud claim, noting that the Directorate of Criminal Investigations report relied upon by the defence was unreliable because the investigating officer had not examined the original auction orders or interviewed the buyers.

The judge also held that the Ministry of Lands’ inability to locate certain records did not constitute proof of fraud and applied the doctrine of res judicata to bar reopening of the auction issue.

Citing a clear chain of ownership through the court decree, auction documents, transfer records and title deed, Justice Asati affirmed the purchasers’ constitutional right to property under Article 40, ending a legal battle that began in 2002.